|
How to Impart Information in Addition to Lecture
Technique: Question,
Dialogue, Weave, Synthesize
Question : What
are the elements of a good question?
- Open-ended (not looking for yes or no)
- Invite sharing about what is known on a particular topic
- No right or wrong answers
- Question should be open to many possible answers, different
points of view
- Questions that 'encourage' participation
- Powerful opening for conversation
- Questions designed to draw distinctions
Caution: Only ask questions to which you truly want
to know the participants answers. If you know THE answer to
a question, don't ask it -simply give the information.
Expertise is a blessing and a curse - the more you know
about your subject the less genuine your questions will appear
to be.
When asking questions, put yourself in learner mode. The
most effective TeleClasses are ones in which the facilitators
want to learn new things as well -every class can be this
opportunity.
Some helpful suggestions:
- In order to access your creativity and wisdom we suggest
you use the following types of questions: Who, What, When,
and How?
- It is usually the "What" question that forces us to be
specific in our query and being specific leads to awareness
and solutions; on the other hand, asking "Why?" leaves you
with only the question.
- We suggest open-ended questions (no right or wrong /
Yes or No answers). This shuts down the flow of connection
and conversation. We want to avoid judging and create space
for conversation. This is not Q & A.
- Encourage people to share personal experiences that will
relieve the pressure of giving a wrong answer (this also
encourages situational application of information fro integration).
- To find the appropriate "What" question to ask, you must
change the focus from details & information to outcomes.
Key Point - Good questions pull your participants
into the conversation and give you the opportunity to share
your key points as you interact.
Examples:
'What is it about leading a Teleclass that interests you?'
'What do you most want your participants to learn from you?'
Note: Research shows that the general length of time
a learner will take to formulate an answer to a question is
10-60 seconds (average 30 sec), depending upon the depth of
the answer or whether they have ever been asked this question
before.
What is the average length of time that the questioner usually
allows for the response? 3-10 seconds. . .
Those participants who are formulating the answer are not
feeling the silence. They are thinking about the answer. The
facilitator is usually the one who is uncomfortable. The basis
of your questions needs to be one of curiosity. Always have
a reason for your question.
Dialogue
"Genuine listening means suspending memory, desire
and judgment--and, for a moment at least, existing for the
other person."
-Michael P. Nichols
As a TeleClass leader it is important to encourage dialogue
and discourage one-to-one conversation. This is known as cross-talking.
Encourage all comments to be directed 'into the group' and
all questions directed to you.
Each voice, both the facilitator's and the responder's speak
'into the group'. One voice will speak the minds of many of
the callers and a new piece of information is also available
to everyone.
If callers start speaking to one another, interrupt and
participate in guiding the comments so that they will have
the net effect of being part of the general exchange of information.
Facilitating a dialogue is a one-person job. If co-facilitating
choose beforehand who will facilitate each segment. The Leader
can then respond directly to the person who has shared and
begin the weave.
What is the difference between discussion and
dialogue?
Dialogue is a way of being in conversation.
"When they are productive, discussions converge
on a conclusion or course of action. On the other hand, dialogues
are diverging; they do not seek agreement, but a richer grasp
of complex issues."
-Dialogue vs Discussion - Excerpt from The Magic
Of Dialogue by Daniel Yankelovich
Dialogue assumes that many people have pieces of the answer
and that together they can craft a solution.
It is collaborative conversation: participants work together
toward common understanding
- About exploring common ground
- Listening to understand, find meaning and agreement
- Re-examining all positions
- Admitting that others' thinking can improve on one's
own
- Searching for strengths and value in others' positions
- Discovering new options, not seeking closure
The difference between dialogue and discussion?
Mutual trust needs to be built before participants of unequal
status can open up honestly with one another.
Three distinctive features of dialogue differentiate it
from discussion. When all three are present, conversation
is transformed into dialogue.
When any one or more of the three features are absent, it
is discussion or some other form of talk, but it is not dialogue.
- Equality and the absence of coercive influences
-all participants must be treated equally. Outside the context
of the dialogue there may be large status differences. In
the dialogue itself equality must reign.
- Listening with Empathy - the ability of participants
to respond with unreserved empathy to the views of others.
The gift of empathy - the ability to think someone else's
thoughts and feel someone else's feelings - is indispensable
to dialogue. If there is discussion without participants
responding empathically to one another, it is discussion,
not dialogue.
- Bringing assumptions into the open - without judgments.
The theorists of dialogue also concur that unlike discussion,
dialogue must be concerned with bringing forth people's
most deeply rooted assumptions. In a dialogue participants
are encouraged to examine their own assumptions and those
of other participants. Once these assumptions are in the
open, they are not to be dismissed out of hand but considered
with respect even when participants disagree with them.
One of the big differences between discussion and dialogue is
this process of bringing assumptions into the open while simultaneously
suspending judgment.
The Leader can then respond directly to the person who has shared
and begin the weave Weaving
Introduce, anchor and / or reinforce key points by responding
to a participant contribution and then segueing into the group:
We are all speaking in to the whole circle:
i.e. "Thank you Linda. That is an important element of a good
question. What I like about what Linda has said is. . ."
Some other elements of great questions are. . ..
Weaving is up to the facilitator:
- Weave the points of content that are not spoken.
- Paraphrase rephrase, anchor, reinforce the key points
from the participants.
- Artful weaving includes balancing the talking and the
listening.
In addition to weaving points raised
by participants, this technique provides an opportunity to
creatively add in other pieces of information through the
segment rather than reciting a list at the beginning or the
end.
Synthesizing
Learners rave about gaining the ability to synthesize 10
different things people are saying into a single crystallized
statement and this can be modelled consistently by the facilitator.
Ask YOUR participants to talk about how they would do this.
Meaning:
- Ask any question, get different answers/view
- Ask participants where they would go NOW given the 10
answers.
- Challenge them to find a way to crystallize/synthesize
to come up with a solution/answer that includes the best
of everyone's thinking.
Summarizing
at the end of Call Segments - after each section of Q-D-W
summarize the key points that were made during the dialogue.
|